If you’ve observed Carvana (NYSE: CVNA) in recent years, the transformation is astonishing. The stock dropped below $5 in late 2022 due to bankruptcy concerns, recovered to around $260 in 2024, and has soared 130% in 2025 — recently trading close to $472. This performance significantly surpasses the S&P 500’s 17% increase, whereas competitor CarMax’s stock has decreased by 50%.
The immediate catalyst is obvious: Carvana will be added to the S&P 500 on December 22, 2025, a decision that generates passive inflows and renews interest from institutional investors. However, the surge isn’t solely attributed to index mechanics. Carvana’s fundamentals have meaningfully improved, featuring increased unit sales, rising revenue, and enhanced operational efficiency.
Nonetheless, momentum has propelled the stock to a valuation that anticipates near-perfect execution. With a market capitalization exceeding $100 billion, CVNA seems overvalued based only on fundamentals. See Buy of Fear Carvana Stock?
We explore what is causing the discrepancy and its implications for investors below. That being said, if you seek growth potential with less volatility than owning an individual stock, consider the High Quality Portfolio. It has vastly outperformed its benchmark—a combination of the S&P 500, Russell 2000, and S&P MidCap indexes—yielding returns exceeding 105% since its inception. What accounts for this? Collectively, HQ Portfolio stocks have generated superior returns with minimized risk compared to the benchmark index, avoiding significant fluctuations, as shown in HQ Portfolio performance metrics. Additionally, check out What’s Next After Sofi Stock’s 117% Surge?
Valuation: Carvana Is in the Stratosphere
Its price-to-sales ratio is around 2.9x, slightly below the index’s 3.2x, but the disparity widens significantly regarding earnings and cash flow. Carvana is traded at roughly 92 times earnings — over three times the S&P 500’s 23 — and about 96 times free cash flow, compared to the index at 20. These valuations for a used-car retailer imply expectations of extremely strong, sustained profitability. Any shortfall introduces significant risk.
Growth: The Bright Spot
If you’re curious about what propels Carvana’s success, this is it.
In the past three years, the company’s revenue has increased at an average rate of 11.6%, which is more than double that of the broader market. In the last twelve months, revenue surged from $13 billion to $18 billion, which is an impressive 46% increase. The latest quarter showed even stronger growth, with revenue rising 54.5% year-over-year to $5.6 billion.
For more information, see: CVNA Revenue Comparison | CVNA Operating Income Comparison
Profitability: Better, But Still Thin
This is where the narrative becomes more complex. Carvana generated $1.7 billion in operating income over the past year, resulting in an operating margin of 9.4%. This represents a significant improvement from the substantial losses in 2022. However, compared to the S&P 500’s nearly 19% average operating margin, it remains slim.
Cash flow indicates a similar trend. Operating cash flow was approximately $666 million, resulting in a cash flow margin of 3.6%, while net income of $629 million reflects a 3.4% net margin. In contrast, the rest of the market typically reports net margins well into the double digits. The business functions — but it is not yet a margin powerhouse.
Financial Stability: Surprisingly Strong
Despite the residual negativity from the 2022 collapse, Carvana emerges from 2025 in a financially robust position.
Debt totals $5.6 billion, modest relative to its market cap, and resulting in a debt-to-equity ratio of roughly 5.5%, comfortably better than the S&P average. Cash and equivalents make up $2.6 billion of $9.9 billion in assets, giving Carvana a cash-to-assets ratio near 27%, far above the broader market’s single-digit level.
Downturn Resilience: This Is the Red Flag
The stock’s significant declines during market disruptions reveal its high-beta characteristic. During the inflation shock of 2022, CVNA plunged 99% from its peak in 2021 — effectively a total loss — as opposed to a 25% decline for the S&P. Although it eventually returned to its prior high by mid-2025, the recovery took 947 days, approximately double the index’s recovery period. In the 2020 pandemic, the stock decreased by 73%, in contrast to a 34% drop for the S&P. While Carvana recovered swiftly from that scenario (in just 77 days, faster than the market), the drawdowns themselves highlight how drastically the stock can fluctuate in both directions. Read CVNA Dip Buyer Analyses to observe how the stock has bounced back from significant declines in the past.
Even in the absence of crises, Carvana tends to react sharply to earnings, projections, and operational updates.
So Where Does This Leave You?
If you appreciate high-octane growth narratives with genuine operational enhancements, Carvana certainly fits the description. The turnaround is authentic, the inclusion in the S&P 500 adds credibility, and the revenue momentum is hard to overlook. However, if you’re investing today, you’re paying a premium that presupposes the next few years progress without any missteps. Carvana can continue to grow, but much of that growth is likely already reflected in the stock price.
You may want to explore the Trefis Reinforced Value (RV) Portfolio, which has outperformed its all-cap benchmark (a blend of the S&P 500, S&P mid-cap, and Russell 2000 benchmark indices) to provide solid returns for investors. What contributes to this success? The quarterly rebalanced mix of large-, mid-, and small-cap RV Portfolio stocks enables a versatile strategy that takes advantage of favorable market conditions while mitigating losses during market downturns, as described in RV Portfolio performance metrics.
Read the full article here